Do Psychological Diagnoses Matter Searching for Mental Health Solutions

 

Mental Health Education Series: Anxiety Disorders

Video taken from the channel: InHealth: A Washington Hospital Channel


 

DSM-5 Sparks Mental Illness Debate | Agenda

Video taken from the channel: DW News


 

New Thoughts About Mental Illness: Implications for Discovery & Treatment

Video taken from the channel: Brain & Behavior Research Foundation


 

Dr Praveen Tripathi Live (answers questions on mental health and psychiatric illnesses)

Video taken from the channel: Dr. Praveen Tripathi


 

Psychological Disorders: Crash Course Psychology #28

Video taken from the channel: CrashCourse


 

Principles of Psychiatric Assessment and Management Diagnosis, Formulation and Management

Video taken from the channel: PsychScene Hub


 

Complex Psychiatric Cases: Diagnosis and Treatment

Video taken from the channel: NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital


Better Mental Health Care. Unfortunately, we treat mental health as simply a disorder in the mind, a bug in the system, a diagnosis to be handled with a specific protocol. This can actually obfuscate things and keep underlying issues from being treated.

Stress is one of the primary factors of poor mental health. Q: Is a psychiatric diagnosis the same as a physical health diagnosis? A: There are similarities and differences. Similarities:Diagnoses in physical health and mental health often use the same type of language such as symptoms, disorders, and illness.

Both medical and psychiatric diagnoses aim to group similar experiences together. When the National Institute of Mental Health concluded that DSM diagnoses do not map underlying causes and cannot be a foundation for mental health research, the American Psychiatric Association. The DSM is considered the definitive guide for mental health professionals, and provides descriptions for all mental health problems and their symptoms. The five chapters analyzed were: bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, depressive disorders, anxiety disorders, and trauma-related disorders. Researchers came to a number of troubling conclusions.

A new study, published in Psychiatry Research, has concluded that psychiatric diagnoses are scientifically worthless as tools to identify discrete mental health disorders. When the National Institute of Mental Health concluded that DSM diagnoses do not map underlying causes and cannot be a foundation for mental health research, the American Psychiatric Association. In addition to recognizing the bias against people with a psychiatric diagnosis, there is general unrest over the validity of psychiatric diagnoses. On April 29, 2013, Dr. Thomas R. Insel, director of the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) posted a blog about the soon-to-be-released DSM-5 by the American Psychiatric Association (APA).

How do I challenge a mental illness diagnosis, verbally and written? I need as much help with this as Answered by a verified Mental Health Professional. We use cookies to give you the best possible experience on our website. His mind seems to be closed on the matter.

The right treatment program begins with the right diagnosis. When teams know exactly what is causing a mental health issue, they can know what to do to help ease symptoms. There are a variety of tested and proven tests doctors can use to help their clients when they seem to be struggling with mental health concerns. The patient is confused and unable to answer questions.

Select the nurse’s best action. a. Record the patient’s answers to questions on the nursing assessment form. b. Ask an advanced practice nurse to perform the assessment interview. c. Call for a mental health advocate to maintain the patient’s rights. d.

List of related literature:

However, since most psychiatric disorders cannot be diagnosed using hard’ tests, even mental health specialists may disagree about the nature of a psychiatric disorder.

“Fitness for Work: The Medical Aspects” by John Hobson, Julia Smedley
from Fitness for Work: The Medical Aspects
by John Hobson, Julia Smedley
Oxford University Press, 2019

Certainly, all of the structured and semistructured diagnostic interviews are designed specifically to aid in psychiatric diagnosis.

“Comprehensive Handbook of Psychological Assessment, Volume 2: Personality Assessment” by Mark J. Hilsenroth, Daniel L. Segal, Michel Hersen
from Comprehensive Handbook of Psychological Assessment, Volume 2: Personality Assessment
by Mark J. Hilsenroth, Daniel L. Segal, Michel Hersen
Wiley, 2003

The clinical interview and assessment in psychiatry are intended to identify whether or not a patient has a mental health problem, the nature of any problem(s), and the specific diagnoses.

“Study Guide to DSM-5®” by Laura Weiss Roberts, Alan K. Louie
from Study Guide to DSM-5®
by Laura Weiss Roberts, Alan K. Louie
American Psychiatric Publishing, 2014

For example, even if a patient’s symptoms fulfill the criteria for Schizotypal Personality Disorder, they may not receive that diagnosis if they have already met the criteria for the diagnosis of Schizophrenia.

“Study Guide to DSM-IV-TR” by Michael A. Fauman
from Study Guide to DSM-IV-TR
by Michael A. Fauman
American Psychiatric Pub., 2002

Across medical settings, psychological evaluations are requested for a specific purpose (even if that purpose is as broad as an “emotional evaluation”) usually termed the referral question.

“Diagnostic Interviewing” by Daniel L. Segal, Michel Hersen
from Diagnostic Interviewing
by Daniel L. Segal, Michel Hersen
Springer US, 2009

Across healthcare settings, psychological evaluations are requested for a specific purpose (even if that purpose is as broad as an “emotional evaluation”) usually termed the referral question.

“Diagnostic Interviewing” by Daniel L. Segal
from Diagnostic Interviewing
by Daniel L. Segal
Springer US, 2019

It is not that psychiatrists and other mental health professionals do not understand the difference between crisis and mental illness, but once a patient is admitted to a medical or hospital establishment, managed care and insurance policies require diagnosing them.

“People in Crisis: Clinical and Diversity Perspectives” by Lee Ann Hoff, Lisa Brown, Miracle R. Hoff
from People in Crisis: Clinical and Diversity Perspectives
by Lee Ann Hoff, Lisa Brown, Miracle R. Hoff
Taylor & Francis, 2011

They put in the MMPI ºnly those questions that were answered differently by a diagnºstic group (e.g., schizophrenic patients).

“Foundations of Psychological Testing: A Practical Approach” by Leslie A. Miller, Robert L. Lovler
from Foundations of Psychological Testing: A Practical Approach
by Leslie A. Miller, Robert L. Lovler
SAGE Publications, 2015

Those with antisocial, schizoid and paranoid personalities may tend not to seek specific help or treatment from mental health services, but rather for other problems, e.g. comorbid disorders such as substance abuse or anxiety, and the presence of personality disorder may be under-recognised or under-diagnosed.

“Companion to Psychiatric Studies E-Book” by Eve C Johnstone, David Cunningham Owens, Stephen M Lawrie, Andrew M McIntosh, Michael D. Sharpe
from Companion to Psychiatric Studies E-Book
by Eve C Johnstone, David Cunningham Owens, et. al.
Elsevier Health Sciences, 2010

Since they are not considered mental disorders, they have no diagnostic criteria nor diagnostic codes.

“Mental Health and Mental Disorders: An Encyclopedia of Conditions, Treatments, and Well-Being [3 volumes]: An Encyclopedia of Conditions, Treatments, and Well-Being” by Len Sperry
from Mental Health and Mental Disorders: An Encyclopedia of Conditions, Treatments, and Well-Being [3 volumes]: An Encyclopedia of Conditions, Treatments, and Well-Being
by Len Sperry
ABC-CLIO, 2015

Alexia Lewis RD

Registered Dietitian Nutritionist and Certified Heath Coach who believes life is better with science, humor, and beautiful, delicious, healthy food.

[email protected]

View all posts

19 comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Doctor!!! Need a small help.. We both share same name and I believe a very similar gmail ID because of which many of your patients are writing to me about their personal problems and request for appointments. It pains me that they are writing to a wrong person and there is a delay in getting right attention. May I request you to have your email ID shared with viewers so that they can reach you, in time.:)

  • Guys i want to ask something, it may not related to the vid. I don’t know but i want to take an abnormal psychology couse and i decided to take it now, i’m only 13 y/o do you think my mind is in the right condition to take such a big course?

  • All mental health problems are caused by severe calcium deficiency. This begins in the womb or in infancy. The human body can assimilate calcium only from fresh, natural, uncooked foods especially leafy greens and grasses, wheatgrass. Artificial supplements do not work. The best way to get the calcium from greens is through green smoothies.

    Brain chemical imbalances have never been proved.

    One of the reasons why mental health problems generally develop or manifest in late adolescence is because of the body’s need for tremendous amounts of calcium due to the sudden spurt in physical growth.

    Calcium is needed for proper neurotransmitter function.

    It is also important to minimise chronic cellular inflammation by avoiding white sugar, refined carbs and oils and fats that increase cellular inflammation.

    Cellular inflammation prevents the absorption of nutrients vitamins and minerals.

  • Its kinda sick that they still strap People to beds even though atleast the People Ive met when Ive been sectioned who were strapped to beds get increasingly worse and tend to have a harder time being let out.

  • Hello doctor first I would say you are very sweet & second I love watching your videos moreover the way you explain its finominal & outstanding ���� lots of love stay blessed ✋��

  • Hii sir main bhut depression me hun per mera help koi nhi kar rahan meri ek chhoti be ti 3 sal ki mere sasural wale bhut torchere karte hai srf bolte hai marja warna mardungi kya karun kucch samajh me nhi aa rahan marne jati hun to beti ko dekh ker khud ko samvalti hun per kab tak akele khud ko samvalo..dr k pass v nhi jane dete or jak v kya karungi mere pass to pesa hi nhi hai

  • Hear that folks, you have to live in such environments in order to behave in such ways. So his life must be perfect in order to make an intellectual design. All environmental pressures have a distress effect

  • Personally, I’ve been at inpatient mental care aka “a mental asylum” four times. It’s not fun, but over the years they’ve gotten a lot better, you’re not treated as quite human though, it is at least sanitary now.

  • Hello Sir, Am fresh viewer of your channel…. If you don’t mind I want your suggestions regarding heart pain from left palm to heart slight pain…. And I have indigestion problem and constipation…. Earlier during lockdown. Am suffering from anxiety and stress due to corona news and studies issues.. now am feel beeter but mild heart pain from left palm to heart since one month…. What can I do for this? How to bal. Hormones.? And Now am taking medicine Levosulpride 25 mg, chlordiazepoxide and Amitriptyline hydrochloride 12.5mg, Esomeprazole 40…. So what should I do for betterment and why pain happen????

  • Guys, it’s 11pm and I literally saw two mostly undetectible things with pointy white shade at one of the side. They were just flying in the sky. I was thinking about the lesson when I noticed it.

  • What if you are a person who cannot have any type of relationships?
    You can only work at a job that keeps you completely isolated from people.
    Just making small talk will offend people. Then it will get you into trouble.
    What if you cannot keep a job. Much less a home?
    What would you call that?

  • Doc Mai bohat depression me hon suicide ki sonch atih hai…AP plz help Kar sakhtey hai…?? jeene ki Wajah bhi toh nhi milre…Kya karu doc??

  • does anyone else choose to procrastinate doing their school work by watching crash course and convincing themselves that it’s okay because its educational

  • 6:58 EXACTLY

    This is my absolute favorite explanation of what mental health is. I want to share this a million + more times. This needs to be common knowledge… I definitely learned a few things from this..

  • GG….
    How was mental health like in Bible times?

    Was it better?
    I think so… Because of spiritual thinking?
    Or walking by the spirit

    Oh lalalah

  • It is hard to get out of mental institutions once in because people get paid to keep you in. The system is set up to make you crazy to justify their income and to sexual abuse crazy people who have no rights. The priest rapes devilish children.

  • Dr. Tripathi, my father is a schizophrenia patient since 27 years. We are watching him suffering since our childhood. Many psychiatry dept. HOD given him treatment but the disease never been cured. Every single day he is taking those anti psychiatry tablets. Since two years he has developed a cycle, in which he becomes normal for 20 days and then become abnormal for another 20 days. Here I keep you remind even in abnormal days he never denied to take his medicines. There is no financial pressure, no family issue or burdon on him. He is an engineer by profession a govt servant and about to retire in few months. Can you help me sir. Please share your contact no.

  • I have OCD. I swear I’m not a villain. I just overthink (O) and overact(C) a lot more than others (D). The BIG words just scar people.

  • Nature goes on forever for everyone and everything to return as everyone and everything an infinite number of times.�� �� �� Deal with it.